On Thursday January 12, New England Conservatory President Tony Woodcock released an “urgent message” stating that Benjamin Zander is “no longer with the institution” – a euphemism for ‘Zander was fired.’
Zander was the beloved conductor of my orchestra, the Youth Philharmonic Orchestra (YPO), and the artistic director at Walnut Hill School for the Arts, a private school affiliated with New England Conservatory (NEC).
After transforming the culture at NEC and Walnut Hill, Zander was allegedly fired because he allowed Peter Benjamin, a registered level two sex offender, the opportunity to continue his career as a videographer after serving time in prison and undergoing therapy.
Woodcock and New England Conservatory’s decision to dismiss Zander was unfair not only to Zander, but also to the Youth Philharmonic Orchestra and the rest of the NEC community.
Perhaps the best way to describe Benjamin is as a “background figure.” He did not record every rehearsal, only our concerts in Jordan Hall. Legally, NEC felt obligated to take action against him.
However, he posed no danger to any orchestra members. I never saw anybody in any contact with him. Zander’s decision to hire Benjamin, while somewhat imprudent because Zander failed to inform the administration of Benjamin’s past, did not jeopardize student musicians. It certainly did not warrant Zander’s dismissal.
Zander was also fired just eight days before a concert packed with extraordinarily complicated music. Our orchestra will now be under the direction of two able conductors, Hugh Wolff and David Loebel, each conducting two pieces. Under these circumstances, though, our ability to perform at the same level we did with Zander is questionable.
Why did Woodcock decide to fire Zander immediately? Was he a threat to the school or the students? No, he was not.
In his letter to YPO, Zander wrote, “I believe that terminating my services as soon as possible had become a priority [to Tony Woodcock].”
If Zander was correct, which I think he was, then we can draw one conclusion: Woodcock was more invested in settling some sort of personal vendetta than in YPO and the student body at NEC and Walnut Hill. His decision was selfish.
Finally, what I find the most astonishing aspect of this ordeal is NEC’s treatment of Zander, despite his contributions to the school over the course of 40 years. Zander attracted students and teachers to the school. He fundraised and donated his own money for incredible orchestra tours like the one to Austria, Slovakia and the Czech Republic that I was a part of last summer. He even convinced rock legend Sting to attend one of our rehearsals.
After Saturday’s rehearsal, the second since Zander’s firing, I spoke with a musician who had been a member of the orchestra for four years. She told me she was unsure if she could continue to play in YPO without Zander. Zander brought these remarkably talented musicians back to NEC each year. He was an invaluable member of the NEC community, and he was banished from the conservatory in an abrupt and unfair manner.
Zander was a leader at NEC. His philosophy, detailed in his book The Art of Possibility, urged people to always maintain a positive outlook and avoid the “downward spiral” of pessimism. Zander made a living through speeches to corporate executives around the world about the importance of classical music and “the art of possibility.” He inspired YPO’s musicians and anyone else who had heard him speak or conduct.
While I was checking my luggage at Logan Airport before flying to Europe with YPO, the attendant recognized Zander several booths down from me.
He told me, “I know that man! He’s Ben Zander, right? I’ve seen his talks on YouTube – he’s amazing.”
Zander influenced people everywhere, and his personality is truly unique. He will be dearly missed at New England Conservatory.
ECRE • Jan 23, 2012 at 3:08 PM
Why is all the responsibility Zander's? Why isn't NEC taking any of the responsibility?
There are many questions left unasked here. Why did NEC allow Zander to hire someone who would be working with minors without any oversight? There are all kinds of legal ramifications here. Also, the videographer, being a sex offender, has responsibilities also. What about his responsibility in all of this? Was it even legal for him to be doing this work?
Robert A. Clifford • Jan 23, 2012 at 2:54 AM
The great suggestion of a newly formed, Boston Youth Orchestra, in light of the ill considered firing of Ben Zander,
ought to be a priority in the coming days, weeks and months…Does anyone, besides Ben and we older folks, remember the origins of his Boston Philharmonic? It was an amazing story, and now Mr. Woodcock and the NEC have, quite possibly and unintentionally, planted a seed that just might grow and flower! The Art of Possibility in action…….What do you say to that, students and parents?
Thomas • Jan 21, 2012 at 10:29 PM
Does the fact that the orchestra is doing Shostakovitch's 5th Symphony. It seems strangely fitting as a response to Woodcock's mess.
Mrs.E • Jan 21, 2012 at 8:41 AM
Thank you so much, Ben R., for your great article. Yes, we need to share with each other, support each other and honor and support Benjamin Zander as much as we are able to—no—MORE than we are able. 🙂 Mrs.E
Anand • Jan 20, 2012 at 9:03 PM
Hi
fantastic article. Quite fitting for this extraordinary man.
I am not a student at NEC, but a musician nevertheless, and also a regular audience of your fantastic performances at NEC. I was very eagerly awaiting this Friday's concert. La mer ! and THE Fifth !1
But instead I am at home typing these words.
I felt that it would be hard to sit and listen to the YPO without Zander conducting. I would really miss what this man can do to a young orchestra. I cannot remember a single performance of Zander where there were no shining eyes among the players, and where the performance was lackluster. I say this given many other concerts at NEC without Zander where the students look like they were slave laborers, almost ready to weep or get out !
But with Zander the students are always totally into the performance.
Although I will attend his BPO concerts, I think it is a big loss to the community that young musicians will not see his enthusiasm.
Here is a suggestion. Why not form a Boston youth orchestra with YPO members ?
Cheers
shari moy • Jan 20, 2012 at 8:59 PM
Profound loss to NEC and for all. Incredible man in an impossible circumstance. We will see you soon Ben Zander. You are the next "Art of Possibility" for all of us.
heidi yenney • Jan 20, 2012 at 7:22 AM
Thank you for your letter.
Has the student body of YPO considered striking or other forms of protest?
Heidi Yenney, NEC Alumn '84 '87 (and Boston Philharmonic '82-'84)
Robin • Jan 20, 2012 at 9:24 AM
Zander has a long history of working 'around' the rules, be it NEC's or the Musicians' Union's regulations. NEC can't risk not knowing what decisions Ben makes on a daily basis if he hides important information like Benjamin's history.
Kris Yenney • Jan 20, 2012 at 12:02 PM
OCCUPY NEC, perhaps!?… Count me IN… WHAT a disappointment/travesty… If only there were MORE good mentors with the kind of Passion and Dedication that Ben Zander lavished on his students, readers and strangers, what a Better World this would be!…
Kris Y. Yenney ~ NEC Alum ('85) and proud mentee of Maestro Benjamin Zander.